
For a driver who gets behind the wheel drunk for the second time, the consequences are dramatically more severe than at a first offence. The law provides for a separate aggravated type of the offence, higher penalties, a mandatory lifetime driving disqualification and the possibility of vehicle forfeiture. It is worth understanding exactly what “recidivism” means in this context.
The Legal Basis – Article 178a § 4 of the Criminal Code
Article 178a § 4 of the Criminal Code provides for an aggravated type of the drink driving offence. The provision applies where the offender was previously finally convicted of operating a motor vehicle while intoxicated, or of the criminal offence under Article 173, 174 or 177 of the Criminal Code committed while intoxicated or under the influence of a narcotic, or committed the offence under Article 178a § 1 during the period of an active disqualification from driving motor vehicles.
The penalty is imprisonment of between three months and five years.
What “Previous Conviction” Means – an Important Distinction
Recidivism under Article 178a § 4 requires a final conviction for the previous offence.
A conditional discontinuance is not a conviction. Where the previous case ended with a conditional discontinuance of proceedings, the offender was not convicted and does not satisfy the recidivism condition of § 4. A subsequent drink driving offence may be assessed as a first offence under Article 178a § 1.
Spent convictions. Whether a spent previous conviction can form the basis for recidivism under § 4 requires individual legal analysis.
A Lifetime Driving Disqualification
Article 42 § 3 of the Criminal Code provides for a mandatory lifetime disqualification from driving all motor vehicles on conviction for the criminal offence under Article 178a § 4 – unless an exceptional case justified by special circumstances exists.
A lifetime disqualification means the permanent loss of the legal right to drive a car, motorcycle or any other motor vehicle. It is the most severe consequence that can befall a driver for a road traffic offence – aside from imprisonment itself.
Vehicle Forfeiture
On conviction for the offence under Article 178a § 4 of the Criminal Code:
Discretionary forfeiture (Article 44b § 1) – the court may order forfeiture of the motor vehicle regardless of the alcohol concentration.
Mandatory forfeiture (Article 44b § 1a) – where the blood alcohol concentration was at least 1.5 per mille, or 0.75 mg/dm³ in exhaled breath, the court orders forfeiture of the vehicle mandatorily – unless an exceptional case justified by special circumstances exists.
Where the vehicle was not solely owned by the offender, the court orders a financial penalty payable to the State Treasury of between PLN 5,000 and PLN 500,000 – mandatorily where sole ownership is absent, and discretionally where forfeiture is impossible or inappropriate for other reasons.
Conditional Discontinuance at the Recidivism Stage – Practically Ruled Out
A conditional discontinuance requires, among other things, a low degree of fault and social harm. Where there is recidivism – a repeat drink driving offence by someone previously convicted – the degree of social harm is high, which practically rules out a conditional discontinuance. Courts in such cases impose convictions.
Insurance Recourse
In drink driving cases – whether a first or subsequent offence – the third-party liability insurer has the right to recourse (Article 43 of the Compulsory Insurance Act). It pays compensation to those injured and then seeks repayment from the driver. In recidivism cases the recourse amounts can be significant – particularly where a collision or accident occurred.
What Can Be Done
At the recidivism stage the defence options are seriously limited – but this does not mean there is nothing to be done. Active defence can influence: the level of the sentence within the statutory range, the possibility of conditionally suspending the custodial sentence, arguments aimed at establishing an exceptional case in relation to the lifetime disqualification or vehicle forfeiture, and the question of sole ownership of the vehicle (co-ownership excludes forfeiture of the vehicle itself and replaces it with a financial penalty).
Contact Us
If you are facing a second drink driving offence, it is worth consulting a lawyer as soon as possible – at the recidivism stage the stakes include not only liberty but a lifetime driving disqualification.
It pays to be properly prepared: both in knowing what you can claim and in having a clear strategy.
We handle cases for drivers in Poznań and across the Wielkopolska region, with in-person and online consultations available for clients elsewhere in Poland.
Adwokat Marta Krzyżanowicz and Adwokat Michalina Koligot Law Firm “Adwokat dla Kierowców w Poznaniu”
ul. Adama Mickiewicza 18/3, 60-834 Poznań
tel. +48 795 001 536 · +48 531 335 713
kontakt@adwokatdlakierowcy.pl · www.adwokatdlakierowcy.pl
This text is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case requires individual analysis.