
Non-material damages are a financial award for the pain, suffering and harm sustained as a result of an accident. Unlike compensation for financial loss, they cannot be measured in receipts and invoices. This is precisely why insurers are most inclined to undervalue them, and injured parties most often do not know how much they are genuinely entitled to.
The Legal Basis – Article 445 § 1 of the Civil Code
Article 445 § 1 of the Civil Code provides that in cases of bodily injury or health disorder the court may award the injured party an appropriate sum as financial compensation for harm suffered.
The provision is deliberately imprecise – “an appropriate sum” is an evaluative concept. Its content is shaped by the case law of the Supreme Court and the common courts, which over decades have developed criteria for assessment and – in recent years – have clearly raised the level of awards.
What Non-Material Damages Cover
Non-material damages are intended to compensate for all intangible consequences of the accident: physical pain during treatment and rehabilitation, psychological suffering (anxiety, depression, PTSD), restrictions on daily activities (sport, hobbies, social life), inability to work or pursue valued activities, permanent disfigurement (scars, amputations, deformities), the discomfort of requiring constant care or assistance from others, and loss of enjoyment of life and future prospects.
Non-material damages are a one-off award – they should cover both past and future suffering. This is why long-term prognosis is taken into account when assessing the amount.
Criteria for Assessment – What the Court Takes Into Account
The Supreme Court has developed a set of criteria for assessing “an appropriate sum.”
The degree and duration of suffering. The more intense the pain and the longer the period of treatment, the higher the award. Months of rehabilitation, repeated surgery and chronic pain justify higher amounts than a single procedure.
The permanence of the consequences. The percentage permanent injury is one of the primary indicators – but not the only one. What matters more is the actual impact of the injury on the life of the specific individual. A 10% permanent injury can be devastating for an athlete and less significant for someone with a sedentary lifestyle.
The age of the injured party. Younger age typically justifies a higher award where the consequences are permanent – a young person with a permanent injury will live with it for decades.
The impact on daily life and activities. Inability to play sport, giving up hobbies, a restricted social life, difficulties in carrying out professional work – all of these are relevant to the assessment of harm.
The prognosis. The prospect of a deterioration in health in the future, the need for further surgery or ongoing treatment justifies a higher award.
Psychological consequences. Anxiety disorders, depression and PTSD following an accident are independent components of the harm suffered and require psychiatric or psychological documentation.
Trends in Case Law
The Supreme Court has repeatedly emphasised that non-material damages must not be token awards and must be “economically meaningful.” The level of awards depends entirely on the circumstances of the specific case – the degree of permanent injury, the age of the injured party, the permanence of the consequences and their impact on their life.
An analysis of comparable judgments in similar cases is one of the most effective tools in negotiations with an insurer and in court proceedings. Judgments of the common courts are available through the Common Courts Judgment Portal. A lawyer handling the case carries out such an analysis and uses it as the basis for formulating a justified claim.
How Insurers Undervalue Non-Material Damages
Insurers use a number of undervaluation techniques. They offer amounts several times lower than those awarded by courts in comparable cases, dispute the causal link between the accident and certain complaints, disregard psychological consequences by focusing exclusively on physical ones, use a low percentage permanent injury figure as the sole criterion – ignoring the actual impact on the injured party’s life – and pay out a low amount quickly in the hope that the injured party will accept it without knowing they could claim more.
How to Pursue the Right Amount Effectively
Medical records from day one. Every medical appointment, every test, every entry in the medical history builds the evidential foundation. Describe all complaints to doctors precisely – both physical and psychological.
Documentation of psychological consequences. A consultation with a psychiatrist or psychologist where anxiety disorders, insomnia, depression or PTSD have emerged after the accident – these are separate components of the harm requiring documentation.
A pain and limitations diary. Keep a record of daily complaints, activity restrictions and the impact of the accident on your life. Courts increasingly treat such diaries as valuable evidence.
Witness testimony. People in the immediate circle can give evidence about how the accident has changed your life. Their testimony complements the medical records.
Analysis of case law. Before submitting a claim to the insurer it is worth analysing court judgments in comparable cases – this is the basis for formulating a justified claim.
Do not accept the first offer. The insurer’s first offer is typically a starting point for negotiation, not a final proposal. An appeal is not only a right – it is often a necessity.
The Possibility of Increasing the Award
Where the injured party’s health has significantly deteriorated after compensation was paid, it is possible to pursue additional non-material damages. This applies where the deterioration was not foreseeable at the time the original amount was assessed.
A settlement with the insurer containing a waiver of all future claims may, however, close this avenue – which is why it is absolutely worth consulting a lawyer before signing any settlement agreement.
Contact Us
If the insurer has offered you an undervalued non-material damages award, or you are unsure how much you can claim, it is worth discussing the matter with a lawyer.
It pays to be properly prepared: both in knowing what you can claim and in having a clear strategy.
We handle cases for drivers in Poznań and across the Wielkopolska region, with in-person and online consultations available for clients elsewhere in Poland.
Adwokat Marta Krzyżanowicz and Adwokat Michalina Koligot Law Firm “Adwokat dla Kierowców w Poznaniu”
ul. Adama Mickiewicza 18/3, 60-834 Poznań
tel. +48 795 001 536 · +48 531 335 713
kontakt@adwokatdlakierowcy.pl · www.adwokatdlakierowcy.pl
This text is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case requires individual analysis.